My Spaniel enjoys these treats, he seems to like the crunch and The point that It isn't a single bite and absent. The resealable packet retains them new and crunchy. These are typically a quality treat, very well built with NO artificial ingredients they usually smell similar to peanut butter. https://socialmediastore.net/story19191638/not-known-details-about-crunchy-chicken-rice-bones-dog-treats-goodboy